Jump to content

Talk:Sharon Burch

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

{{WikiProject Women in Music |class=Stub |importance=Low} How do I get a hold of Sharon Burch? We are wanting for her to come entertain at our women’s gathering

Sharon Burch entry arguments against proposed deletion

[edit]

A user called OohBunnies! "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:OohBunnies%21" suggested this article fails to adhere to General Notability Guidelines (GNG).

Actually I can see why it is proposed for deletion.

When I wrote it I wanted to know more about a person who had made some music and events or speeches (I don't remember) relating to Native Americans. Now I can see that there must be a limit for notability, more so in order for Wikipedia to survive, maybe?

I wanted Wikipedia to be able to give honest answers about people who had published literature or music, and I think Sharon Burch falls into that category. However, even publishing today is not what it once was, a guarantee that some people had made a review and found the stories, novels, art, music or textbook interesting enough. Well I need to read more about GNG. What does this translate into: "significant coverage in secondary sources"-

For now I add references and then remove the proposed deletion.

I am shocked by your name "OohBunnies!" on Wikipedia, and I wonder if you are a serious person, but for now I am not digging into that. You may have seen a controversial (very religious bio-article which I tried to write) was criticized, and you may think that this author was an easy "target". I have once before been up against an editor who really only wanted to get power over Wikipedia in order to spread some political messages, a user who was expelled, so therefore I am going into details about your identity later. --d-axel (talk) 10:07, 23 April 2012 (UTC)[reply]