Jump to content

Talk:Ed, Edd n Eddy/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]

I'm putting this on hold for now. The article, in my opinion, is a mess, but I don't think it's quite beyond repair.

  • "Premise" section is totally unsourced.
  • "one of the last, if not the last, of the original Cartoon Cartoons still on the air." Is this acceptable phrasing?
  • "It is currently the longest-running original cartoon on Cartoon Network." I've been told not to use "currently". Perhaps "as of 2008"?
  • Overview is mostly unsourced as well.
  • Original research in many places ("similar to Squigglevision", everything pertaining to pop culture references, AKA appearances), etc.
  • Characters: Can this be summarized in prose instead of a list?
  • Awards and nominations are unsourced.
  • Surely there's more critical reaction than this.
  • "Other Works" section is unsourced.
  • Most references are not formatted with {{cite web}}. There are other problems with the formatting of references as well.
  • Is reference 1 (which is also references 2 and 4) reliable? What about reference 11?
  • Overall, I think there should be much more to say than this. The article seems too short for GA class.

Ten Pound Hammer and his otters(Broken clamshellsOtter chirpsHELP!) 18:56, 30 July 2008 (UTC)[reply]